The Hidden Costs Of Running Your Network
©2001
With the advances in technology comes complexity. In the
past (before computers), a manager who wrote a check for
a typewriter knew that there were other necessary expenses
associated with its use, such as typewriter ribbons and
electrical hookups. Savvy business owners watched these
expenses closely, years before the acronym "TCO" (Total
Cost of Ownership) was in use. They had to justify the costs
with savings on the bottom line, judging improved efficiency
or increased work volume, and make purchasing decisions
based on these judgments.
Watching over the TCO of computer systems in corporations
is usually the responsibility of the Information Systems
(IS) Manager or the Chief Finance Officer (CFO). Networks
are necessary to run even the smallest companies. Those
without such officers can easily be unaware of the importance
of controlling their TCO. A poorly maintained network or
troublesome workstation negatively affects a company's bottom
line in many ways, ways which are not always apparent.
In a typical office with a local area network, staff arrives
early one Monday morning to find that they can't log in
to their workstations. The manager keeps later hours, but
gets a call at home, since there are several workers upset
that they can't start working. She hurries in and finds
that indeed, no one can get into the network. Further investigation
shows the server is up and running, but the backup has failed.
A call to the local computer servicing vendor brings a technician
on-site an hour later, who starts his diagnostics. Bringing
down the entire network and powering off the hubs, the tech
slowly brings the network back to life and staff can finally
work. The backup, however, must be re-done, resulting in
further delays from the staff. In the meantime, more diagnostics
is necessary to find out why it failed.
How
much money did this network glitch cost the firm? Ten staffers
and a manager doing virtually no work for three and a half
hours, then working overtime to catch up that evening, amounted
to quite an expense. Yet the office manager may point to
the technician's bill as the sole cost of the computer network
failure.
There are many types of costs related to the operation
of computers in an office. Some of these include:
- Initial purchase price
- Installation and distribution of PC's
- Purchase of software and training of staff
- Cost effectiveness of purchasing equipment at the right
time
- Time lost by users when the server is down or the PC
fails
- Time lost by key employees when a staff member's PC
is having difficulties
- Cost of administering users (login info, security, etc.)
- Cost of space, security and environment for server (i.e.
air conditioned server room)
- Cost of administering and maintaining backups
- Cost of employing technicians to diagnose and repair
network or PC's
- Cost of office staff trying to correct a problem and
actually causing further problems
- Cost of auditing all equipment; which user has what
and where is it?
- Cost of constant hardware evaluation when new technology
is developed, etc.
- System and server upgrades as increased performance
is required by applications
- Cost of additional insurance on the increased value
of server-based network and more expensive workstations
Yes, many of these costs are intangible; you don't see the
money in your checkbook ledger. But they are real. In looking
at TCO estimates, I found corporations use averages from $5,000
to over $10,000 per PC per year when they analyze their TCO
for bottom line calculations.
"The Gartner Group has stated that a typical enterprise
with 2,000 PC’s currently spends an average of $19M per
annum in direct and hidden costs for computing - that is
$9,500 per PC, " explains Fujitsu Computers Ltd. This number
includes the cost of staffing of IS departments required
to administer a great number of workstations.
Smaller firms may have an on-site technician or administrator
full-time, at an average cost of $50,000 per year, or may
have part-time or service company techs available. My own
TCO estimate for firms of less than 50 users is closer to
$2,000 per year per PC. Thus a 15-user network costs, on
the average, $30,000 per annum, including all the factors
listed above.
You
may wonder what a company can do to minimize their TCO.
Reducing bandwidth (volume of network traffic) and administration
can be a key in shrinking the TCO. Network failures are
much more likely the higher the usage is in the network
cabling system. Unfortunately, business applications have
been growing in size and bandwidth requirements as companies
need more and more sophistication in their software in order
to compete.
Switching to an Application Server Provider, such as WorldPOINT,
can greatly diminish your TCO by minimizing network traffic
and shifting the burden of administering and monitoring
the applications to the host company. Only Internet access
is necessary from the network, rather than the transfer
of the myriad of files necessary to run a bulky application.
As performance becomes an issue, the ASP is responsible
for its improvement. User and backup administration is also
a burden relieved.
Thin client technology (a thin client is a computer without
drives whose sole function is to act as a terminal) not
only greatly reduces bandwidth, but is less expensive. This
implementation can be accomplished through a Citrix server
either at the company's own site or on an ASP's site. As
before, it makes sense to shift as much of the costs as
possible to an ASP.
Total Cost of Ownership should be calculated by all companies,
not just large corporations. Even a single PC has cost factors
associated with it and one must be aware of the effect of
purchasing on the TCO. At the very least, using an average
cost per computer, like $2,000 per year, will give a manager
the means to plan for expenses and allow comparisons in
the decision-making process. You may well find that modifying
network schemes, such as utilizing an ASP or updating to
higher quality wiring or equipment, can quickly pay for
itself.
If you have more questions or any comments, feel free to
e-mail me at jack@worldpointinc.com.
Note:
WorldPOINT articles are copyrighted and the exclusive property
of WorldPOINT Inc. and author Jack Huber. They may be copied
or reproduced by non-ASP's and non-competitors only in their
entirety with no modifications, including the source and
byline, and distributed without charge or financial gain.